PDA

View Full Version : Immigration a cause for pressured maternity services?



Dappy
01-05-11, 10:54 AM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1382374/The-NHS-hospital-80-cent-babies-foreign-mothers.html?ito=feeds-newsxml#




Just one baby in five born in one NHS ¬hospital has a British mother, new figures have revealed.

Of the 3,289 children born at Ealing Hospital, West London, in the past year, a remarkable 2,655 were to foreign nationals.

The statistics – released following a Freedom of Information request by The Mail on Sunday also show that the maternity unit dealt witha total of 104 different nationalities in the 12 months to February.


Baby boom: Births at Ealing Hospital in West London have increased by 500 a year since 2006

These include 537 babies born to Indian mothers – the largest minority ethnic group – 389 Poles, 270 Sri Lankans, 260 Somalians, 200 Afghans and 208 Pakistanis. In contrast, of the 634 babies with British mothers, just three were from Wales and six from Scotland.

Maternity services at the hospital have been coming under increasing pressure, with a 20 per cent rise in births over the past five years, almost twice the national average.

The hospital has had to take on 32 extra ¬midwives to cope with the boom, which saw 500 more babies delivered there last year than in 2006.

A key factor is that foreign women tend to have more babies than British women – an average of 2.5 compared with 1.84 for UK nationals – and Ealing is one of the most ethnically diverse boroughs in Britain.

The figures are derived from how mothers declared their nationality on hospital paperwork, so the ¬British category also covers foreign-born mothers granted British passports and second-generation immigrants who were born British citizens.

Nationally, one baby in four is born to a foreign mother, twice the level of 1997, when Labour came to power. Conservative MP James Clappison said: ‘The Labour Government has left us with significant challenges after an unprecedented wave of inward migration.

‘The pressures, I’m sure, are being felt all over the place including in the NHS. I fully support the present Government’s proposals to cap migration.’


Feeling the strain: Maternity services at the hospital have been coming under increasing pressure

Despite the burgeoning birth rates, Ealing Hospital denies that its maternity services are under strain.

Yet the Royal College of Midwives* recently warned that maternity units across the country were ‘teetering on the brink’ under the pressure of rising birth rates.

And some mothers have complained about being left alone during labour at Ealing Hospital.

Father Paul at the Polish Catholic Community Centre in the borough said he had spoken to many new mothers who were unhappy about their experience at Ealing Hospital. He said: ‘Some women say it is not very good and that the service they would receive in Poland would be better.

‘Doctors are involved much earlier in their pregnancy in Poland and the service is more complex and detailed.’

In July 2008, watchdogs at the Healthcare Commission rated Ealing Hospital’s maternity unit as one of the weakest in the country. It put the unit in the bottom fifth of hospitals for childbirth and ante-natal services, placing it in the ‘least well performing’ category.

However, the service has improved in recent years, according to the new health regulator, the Care Quality Commission. Results of its survey published in December 2010, rated Ealing’s maternity unit 7.8 out of 10, on a par with most NHS Trusts in the country.

A spokeswoman for Ealing Hospital NHS Trust said the hospital catered for a diverse borough and that it was ‘no surprise’ that a high proportion of mothers at its ¬maternity unit were from outside the UK

And she said that a team of translators were on hand to help foreign mothers.

She said: ‘As with the rest of the UK, the Trust has seen a steady increase in the birth rate during the last few years. As with other hospital Trusts that serve diverse populations, clinical staff have access to support workers and systems that aid communication with patients.

‘The maternity services at Ealing Hospital NHS Trust are not under strain and the Trust has achieved and maintains good staff-to-mother ratios in the maternity department.

‘Between 2006 and 2011, the Trust employed a further 32 midwives as a response to increased demand for maternity services and to improve staff-to-mother ratios.’*



Thoughts?

Is the way immigration has been handled to blame for these figures? Is it to blame for the pressure on our maternity services?

What do you think?

MrsBanks
01-05-11, 11:19 AM
I would suggest cost cutting is to blame, not immigration. If hospitals were adequately staffed they would be able to cope with the rising birth rate, regardless of the origin of the mother. I can understand that language difficulties would present a unique challenge for foreign nationals if their english is poor but that is another matter altogether and with enough midwives and time for each woman it would be much less of an issue.

lizzybeltane
01-05-11, 11:32 AM
Oh god this makes me really angry :( why do we live in a country where the general population think it is acceptable to blame every thing on immigration. The figures also look somewhat sus to me are they really saying that 2/3 rds of these women were temporary residents? `or are they infact looking at ethnic origin of british citizens. I am currently a student in a very diverse area but it is a very low percent of the women that we care for that do not have a right to be in this country and those women that are here under these rare circumstances are actually sent a bill for there care from the NHS!!!! I have worked midwives with differing opinions on this subject. Partly some of the questions that we ask these women at booking are irrelevant and quite frankly rude. The questions that we ask lend us towards a personal opinion of these women even if we still are able to act in a professional manner. I think it is our job to care for women holistically the only relevance to ethnic origin is for particular screening, sickle cell, diabeties etc or BCG vaccinations but we could actually use common sense in these matters. I think asking inpertanant questions makes midwives question their beliefs and alienates women thus putting them at greater risk as they may not trust maternity provision. Sadly some of the most beautiful women i have cared for whose stories and demeniour have really touched my soul were actually asylum seekers living in accommodation tantamount to prison. These women are singled out and do not know if there home here is secure and they are so vulnerable :crying: I was raised to be proud to be british because we lived in a country that would protect those in need and welcome diversity into our culture. Just because industry here is failing and we are living beyond our means we should not look to blame each other, the truth is we are all to blame for wanting too much from live and living in a debt culture. The facts of the matter are simple we know the population figures, we know the birth rate but funding to the maternity services has not risen accordingly, we are an unglamorous end of the health care system, if you want to blame anything blame the drug companies that are charging so much for cancer medication, or new medication for MS, flu vaccines etc this is where the heath care funding goes into the pocket of multinational companies. Saving lives = headlines, beating old age and operations for lifestyle choices such as gastric banding, or even IVF. women have babies they always have and always will they are not a consumer group that have a choice and often they do not have a voice, as long as we are not losing too many........
:unsure: Obviously i am aware this is probably not your opinion at all. I am ranting because sadly i have seen that many people that work in the system are of this opinion probably because of media bombardment, so much easier to blame others than to look at our own lives and take self responsibility.

MrsBanks
01-05-11, 11:37 AM
I agree with you 100% Lizzie. It's late here and I am knackered or I would have attempted a longer reply but I think you have hit the nail on the head with the migrants to the UK (and the same happens in Australia, although most people seem quite happy that I am here because the legacy of the White Australia policy is still felt here) being unfairly blamed for every problem that comes along.

ContraryMary
01-05-11, 12:40 PM
Oh god this makes me really angry :( why do we live in a country where the general population think it is acceptable to blame every thing on immigration.

I sincerely hope that the readership of the Daily Fail is NOT considered the general population!!! I think the rest of the population has evolved somewhat! The newspaper caters for the section of our society that still scrapes its knuckles along the floor and grunts the national anthem.

lizzybeltane
01-05-11, 12:57 PM
HAHA i sadly live in a place where the general population have not evolved, infact my neighbors openly vote BNP :blink:

Dappy
01-05-11, 04:01 PM
Well said Lizzy and I completely agree, it doesn't bother me where someone is from. My family weren't originally from the UK.

I think we as a country can't help but try and find so done to blame. It's a shame we as a country can't hold our hands up and say "yeah we fucked up"!